The Element of Alternative Liability Essay

The alternate liability theory is most frequently used when two or more tort-feasors at the same time commit independent Acts of the Apostless of carelessness. but merely one act causes the hurt. the complainant is so relieved from the load of cogent evidence with regard to causing. and may action both tort-feasors without direct cogent evidence of causing. However. the load therefore displacements to the suspect to acquit them. Otherwise. suspects will be held joint and independently apt.

In add-on. the alternate liability theory has a really limited application. and is merely used if all possible offenders have been brought before the tribunal. If I understand this theory right I believe that the tribunals should allow the complainant parents their gesture to switch the load of cogent evidence with response to causing to Dr. Brady based on this theory.

The ground I say this is because Dr. Brady was called in and did non determine any information on the baby’s place before the usage of forceps to present the babe. Dr. Cohn made the first diagnosing. nevertheless we don’t cognize if the hurts were caused before the kid was delivered with the forceps. or during the bringing when Dr. Brady stepped in. Therefore. I would hold to presume that the hurts were caused by Dr. Brady and Dr. Brady should be held apt. Dr. Brady decided to do the bringing without any cognition of the jobs during bringing and even seek to diagnosis himself what place the babe was in before he made the bringing. How can any determinations be made that Dr. Brady did non do those hurts while presenting that babe?

How can another Dr. merely handle a patient without cognition of what is traveling on? If there is no cognition how can he do a clear and concise diagnosing? In my sentiment I believe that both of the doctor’s should be held apt due to the fact that Dr. Cohn gave a unlawful diagnosing. and Dr. Brady made determinations without a diagnosing at all. However. the inquiry was if Dr. Brady should be held apt and I believe that he should. There was causing and carelessness on the portion of Dr. Brady. and Dr. Brady should be held apt.