Greek Debt Crisis in the global recession
One of the most reeling economic systems in the Eurozone is Greece. Though it constitutes less than 3 % of the GDP of the full Eurozone, the troubled economic system has raised excessively many inquiries that economic experts have non been able to reply convincingly.
The biggest benefit a member of Eurozone gets is attract foreign investors easy because of common powerful currency and had to pay a low involvement rate for bonds. Other benefits that were associated with being in Eurozone were increase in trade, touristry ; decrease in hazard due to interchange rate. Due to these benefits, Greece fudged its histories to come in Eurozone in 2000 which it publically admitted in Nov 2004.
It ne’er fulfilled the eligibility to come in Eurozone because of high public debt and budget shortage. Easy entree and foolhardy disbursement further increased the public debt and budget shortage. US investing bankers besides entered trades with the Greece authorities on currency barter derived functions that unnaturally increased the recognition of the state by $ 1 billion and farther masked its shortage.
When the US recession spread across the universe in 2008, Greece was besides affected and its income was significantly affected. But because of high public debt, investors speculated that Greece might default and this led to the sale of investings ( bonds, stocks ) in Greece. Investing dried up and Greece found it even hard to keep the budget shortage and put the state on a slow growing path. As a contagious disease consequence, other similar European economic systems e.g. Portugal, Italy, Spain and Ireland besides became the victim of guess. Soon, investors across the universe became wary of the fiscal crisis and investing across the universe reduced. As a consequence, bond monetary values fell and stock markets crashed all over the universe. Thus, even a little portion of Eurozone resulted in a crisis that impacted the whole universe.
Consequently, Greece asked for bailout from IMF and other strong Eurozone members so that it can retrieve from the terrible crisis. After worsening the petition mentioning assorted political and economic grounds, a bailout bundle of $ 110 billion was sanctioned in May which was to be rolled out in three stages till 2013. However, due to the asceticism thrust and debt decrease measures that semen with bailout bundle, economic experts opine that Greece will come in another recession that will take 8-9 old ages for recovery.
Further, other troubled economic systems in PIIGS may besides inquire for bailout which may be hard for IMF and other Eurozone members because of the immense size of Spain and Italy as compared to Greece. In that instance, because of the asceticism thrust, another recession will hit the full universe which might be of a larger graduated table than the US recession.
A debt crisis is the crisis that occurs due to the inability to pay one ‘s debt. This happens when one loan is taken to refund other loans and the procedure continues. Debt crisis by and large happens in developing states due to assorted factors and affects many coevalss that follow. Developing states face low degrees of income, high degrees of unemployment, unstable currency, high poorness degrees etc. All these are caused due to the debt crisis that these states face that hinder their development. The debt crisis can efficaciously get the better of by assorted schemes over different sectors of the economic system and a well-laid program for managing this.
Overview of Greece economic system
Greece is a capitalist economic system and 40 % of its GDP1 is accounted for by the populace sector and its per capita GDP is about two tierces that of the taking Euro economies.15 % of GDP is being contributed by tourism.20 % of work force is taken over by immigrants, chiefly in unskilled and agricultural occupations. Greece is one of the major donees of EU assistance. Greece economic system grew by over 4 % in old ages 2003-2007 chiefly due to the Olympics games that happened in Athens in 2004 whose substructure disbursement was significant and another ground was the increased handiness of recognition which resulted in sustained degrees of disbursement by consumer. This growing could non prolong itself for long ensuing in a autumn by 2 % in 2008 and recession followed in 2009 ensuing in the lessening of growing by another 2 % caused by the fiscal crisis faced by the universe, less recognition and turning budget shortage and deficiency of steps to undertake the same.
The EU ‘s Growth and Stability Pact citing that budget shortage should non transcend 3 % was violated by Greece in 2007-08 though it was all traveling good from 2003-06.In 2009, the shortage increased voluminously and touched 13.7 % of GDP. Greece has its public debt, unemployment and rising prices above the EU norm but per-capita income is below. The state has been rated really low in international debt evaluation due to the gnawing public fundss, misrepresented statistics, consistent underperformance in the reforms front. Due to the intense force per unit area from the EU and the international market participants, Greece has taken some steps to diminish the revenue enhancement equivocation, better wellness attention reforms, cut authorities disbursement, better pension systems and better fight and present better labour and merchandise markets. Athens faces powerful vocal resistance due its unpopular reforms. Grecian labour brotherhoods are seeking hard to convey in new asceticism steps but the impact has been limited so far.
In April 2010, a taking recognition bureau assigned Greece the lowest possible recognition. In May, the IMF and Eurozone authoritiess provided Greece with loans deserving $ 147 billion to refund its debt to creditors. This was one of the largest bailouts and as an exchange, the authorities has announced disbursement cuts and revenue enhancement additions to bring forth $ 40 billion over 3 old ages in add-on to the other steps.
Overview of Euro and EuroZone
EuroZone is the corporate group of states which have Euro as their recognized currency. The EuroZone came to existence in 1999. It ab initio had 11 states and this grew to 16 by 2009. This does non include every state in the European Union. The members of EuroZone must utilize Euro as its exclusive legal currency. The European Central Bank ( ECB ) is responsible for making and keeping the pecuniary regulations.
The states in EuroZone are supposed to follow the convergence standards
No more than 1.5 per centum points higher than the norm of the three best acting ( lowest rising prices, which may be negative ) member provinces of the EU.
Annual authorities shortage: The ratio of the one-year authorities shortage to GDP must non transcend 3 % at the terminal of the predating financial year2.
Government debt: The ratio of gross govt debt to GDP must non transcend 60 % at the terminal of the predating financial twelvemonth.
Exchange rate: Applicant states should hold joined the exchange rate mechanism under the European Monetary Sytem ( EMS ) for two back-to-back old ages and should non hold devalued its currency during the period.
Long-run involvement rates:
The nominal long-run involvement rate must non be more than 2 per centum points higher than in the three lowest rising prices member provinces.
The symbol for the euro is a alteration of the English alphabet E-rounded “ Tocopherol ” with two cross lines – a‚¬ . Euros are divided into eurocents, each eurocent is one one percent of a euro.
Formation of the EU
11 European Union states met the convergence standards In 1998 ( ( Austria, Belgium, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Portugal, and Spain ) . The Eurozone came into being with the official launch of the euro on 1 January 1999. Greece qualified in 2000 and was admitted on 1 January 2001. Physical coins and bills were introduced on 1 January 2002. Presently, there are 16 member provinces with 329 million people in the eurozone. Euro is the Official currency of the EuroZone. It is besides the 2nd largest modesty currency. It is the 2nd largest traded currency in the universe after the US dollar. It is managed and administered by the ECB ( European Central Bank ) which sets the pecuniary policy. Presently, merely 16 of the 27 members of the EU are members of the EuroZone.
History of the Euro
The Euro became the official currency of the EuroZone members on 1 Jan,1000.The European Currency Unit ( ECU ) was replaced in a ratio of 1:1 by the Euro. Bills were launched merely in 2002 in the EuroZone. The first nine old ages with the common currency Euro went good harmonizing to outlooks but so the fiscal crisis of Greece during 2009-2010 gave a batch of emphasis to the whole of Europe due to the common currency.
1 January 1999
1 January 1999
1 January 2008
1 January 1999
1 January 1999
1 January 1999
1 January 2001
1 January 1999
1 January 1999
1 January 1999
1 January 2008
1 January 1999
1 January 1999
1 January 2009
1 January 2007
1 January 1999
Changes brought approximately by the Euro
The Euro helped increase trade within the Eurozone from 5 to 10 % .
Surveies have found that there has been a positive influence of the Euro on investing. FDI increased by around 20 % in the EuroZone in the first 4 years2. Corporate investing besides increased after the debut of the Euro because of the easier entree. Harmonizing to a survey, the debut of the Euro histories for 22 % of the investing rate since 1998 for states that had a weak currency.
There has been a popular belief among people that the debut of the Euro has caused an addition in the monetary values, particularly in the instance of inexpensive goods which are often purchased.
Exchange rate hazard
A common currency helps in decrease of the overall hazard associated with exchange rate fluctuations. Euro reduced the market hazard exposures for nonfinancial houses both in and outside Europe.
The Euro has helped in fiscal integrating by diminishing the cost of trade in equity, bonds and banking assets in the EuroZone. There has been an integrating in the investings in bond portfolios excessively because the EuroZone states lend and borrow amongst each other much more than with states outdoors.
Consequence on involvement rates
The Euro has helped diminish the involvement rates of the member states particularly those with a weak currency. Thus the value of such houses have increased well.
Tourism has increased by approximately 6.5 % due to the debut of the Euro.
Euro Vs US Dollar over the old ages
The ECB targets involvement rates instead than exchange rates. It does non step in on the foreign exchange rate markets, because of the deductions of the Mundell-Fleming Model which suggest that a cardinal bank can non keep involvement rate and exchange rate marks at the same time because increasing the money supply consequences in a depreciation of the currency.
How Greece got into this problem
The basic job with the Greece economic system since early 2000s has been inordinate disbursement with borrowed money and really low authorities gross. Over the old ages, it has kept on increasing authorities outgo by borrowing immense sums from investors which resulted in a steady Budget Deficit. After a certain point, investors realized that the budget shortage of Greece is manner beyond control and it may non be able to do payments to the investors i.e. Greece might default. This significantly impacted the adoption capacity of the state and investing dried out. Further, the 2008 US recession caused significant loss in income. This farther questioned the ability of Greece to refund its investors and this is called Greece autonomous debt crisis.
The assorted elements that contributed to the debt crisis are discussed below in item.
Cheaper adoption from Eurozone
Increased recognition with the aid of Investment Bankers
Recognition Default Swap
Large scale revenue enhancement equivocation
Cheaper adoption from Eurozone
Though Eurozone was formed in Jan 1, 1999, Greece was unable to fall in at that clip because of it failed to run into the Euro convergence standards of holding a budget shortage non transcending 3 % of GDP and public debt non transcending 60 % of GDP3. But subsequently Greece proved conformity of the convergence standards and joined Eurozone in 1st Jan 2001 as its 12th and weakest member.
The individual most of import benefit of being a portion of Eurozone is to follow the common currency ‘Euro ‘ which was turning to go the most powerful currency of the universe. Since Euro is the common currency in the full Eurozone which included powerful economic systems like France and Germany, come ining Eurozone meant cheaper adoption.
This can be explained by the undermentioned relation.
where it = involvement rate for bonds in domestic economic system
it* = involvement rate for bonds in foreign states
Et = current Exchange rate
Et+1 = expected Exchange rate in future
Since loaning and adoption in Eurozone will be in Euro merely, exchange rate does non come into image and therefore the involvement rate in all member states will be theoretically the same. Greece could hold borrowed at the same rate as Germany/France can despite the huge differences in their sizes and construction.
Due to easy entree to financess, Greece could borrow immense sums and spent recklessly without being scrupulous plenty to see the return on investings.
Increased recognition with the aid of Investment Bankers
Investing Bankss from the United States entered a Currency trading derived functions trade with the Greece authorities that helped Greece dissemble its true deficit4.
Currency trading derived functions are fiscal instruments that are by and large used for refinancing an economic system. Generally such instruments help authoritiess borrow money from other states in foreign currencies i.e. Yen, Dollars etc, but Euros are required to pay day-to-day measures. Maturity sum is to be paid in original foreign denomination.
However, in the particular understanding between Goldman Sachs and Greece, the exchange rate that was used was a fictional one which helped Greece borrow about $ 1 billion5 more than it would hold otherwise. Therefore, Goldman Sachs arranged for an extra $ 1 billion recognition for Greece and in bend received a brawny committee for the trade.
Further, since this was a ‘Swap ‘ derivative, it did non look in the histories of Greece and therefore did non come to notice of Eurostat that checks the economic wellness of Eurozone member states. Therefore, Greece was able to dissemble $ 1 billion of debt due to the Currency-swap derivative instrument.
Recognition Default Swap
Gambling and guesss by Investment Bankss made it highly hard for Greece to borrow money from investors.
Major Investing bankers speculated that Greece will non be able to purchase make payments towards adulthood and vouchers and is likely to default really shortly. This led to the sale of insurance policies that guards the involvements of investors in instance an economic system fails.
These contracts termed credit-default swaps5, efficaciously allowed Bankss and fudge financess wager on a default by a company or, in this instance, an full state i.e. Greece. If Greece fails to pay for its debts, proprietors of these insurance policies can do net income.
Before the debt crisis came to headlines, JP Morgan Chase and about a twelve other Bankss created an index that gave market participants a platform to wager on whether Greece and other similar European states default on their immense debts. Such derived functions are said to hold a important function in Europe ‘s debt crisis, as major participants across the Earth gambled on the failure of the economic system of Greece.
This resulted in a barbarous circle. As Bankss and investors rushed to purchase such barters, these barters became more and more dearly-won. Alarmed by such baleful signals, Greece authorities bonds were shunned in the market and thereby decreased its monetary values. This in bend resulted in high involvement rates that Greece now was required to pay and therefore farther increased guesss about default by Greece.
In late January and early February, as demand for barters protection kept on surging, investors in Grecian bonds abstained from the market, raising inquiries about whether Greece could happen investors for purchasing its bond.
The Markit index, which is established to merchandise such recognition default barters, is made up of 15 most to a great extent traded recognition default barters in Europe and screens similar other troubled states like Italy, Portugal and Spain. As inquiries about those states ‘ debts moved markets around the universe in February, trading in the Markit index sky-rocketed6.
In February, demand for such barter instruments hit $ 109.3 billion, 100 % more than its value of $ 52.9 billion in January. Since Gallic Bankss held $ 75.4 billion of Grecian debt, Swiss establishments held $ 64 billion and German Bankss ‘ exposure stands at $ 43.2 billion, they were among the major purchasers of Credit Default Swaps.
Massive purchase of recognition default barters kept on increasing Markit index which meant higher opportunities of default and therefore resulted in even higher cost of debt for Greece.
Greece has ever been a spend-all state which kept on a high disbursement spree even with borrowed financess. It paid its employees 14 month ‘s salary7 every twelvemonth and besides paid immense vacation fillips even if it was incurring a really high budget shortage.
[ Workers ‘ remittals and compensation of employees ; paid ( US dollar ) in Greece ]
[ Greece Government Budget shortage as a per centum of GDP ]
Large scale revenue enhancement equivocation
One of the major jobs that consequences in really low authorities income is big scale revenue enhancement equivocation. Annual revenue enhancement loss in Greece is estimated at $ 20.5 billion8 which can assist the fighting economic system pay off a important ball of its budget shortage.
[ Shadow economic system on history of revenue enhancement equivocation in Eurozone ]
As it can be observed from the above graph, the economic systems that are fighting the most are the 1s which have highest revenue enhancement equivocation because of major loopholes in the revenue enhancement aggregation system and particular discounts that are offered in many fortunes.
Hedging revenue enhancements is a norm in Greece and citizens feel proud of revenue enhancement equivocation. This has made it even more hard for the authorities to control the issue.
Impact of Greece Debt Crisis
The impact of Greece debt crisis was monolithic and it was non merely limited to Greece and Eurozone, but spread across the universe.
Impact on Greece
Due to steady addition in Markit Index on history of high sale of Credit Default Swaps and guesss, investors lost assurance in Greece. Credit evaluation bureaus like Fitch and S & A ; P downgraded Greece ‘s recognition evaluation to all clip low degrees. This severely hurt investing in Greece.
Further, investors all over the universe started selling Greek investings which led to fall in bond monetary values. High hazard resulted in demand of high hazard premium ( involvement rate ) by the investors i.e. cost of debt increased well for Greece. In April 2010, the bond involvement rates were 650 footing points higher than that of Germany.
When it was revealed that Greece was supposed to do payment of a‚¬54 billion10 towards adulthood and voucher rates in 2010, opportunities of default further increased.
Due to the cumulative impact of all these grounds, investors withdrew from Greece and investing dried up which allow to foster jobs in seting the debt crisis and greatly slowed down the economic system.
[ Interest rates for 10 twelvemonth bonds in Greece and Germany ]
Impact on Eurozone
Due to the distressing economic status in Greece and other PIIGS state in Europe ( Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Spain ) , investors became really cautious and felt that the crisis would distribute to the full Eurozone and impact other economic systems even if they ‘re making good. This is called Contagion or Dominion effect9. Consequently, they sold off bonds of other states as good. This reduced bond monetary values and hence increased the involvement rate on those bonds. Turning involvement rate for bonds in fighting economic systems made it really hard for them to pull investors. This made it further hard to return to growing path and cut down budget shortage.
[ Interest rates for 10 twelvemonth bonds in Italy and Spain ]
Investors in stock markets besides sold off their investings quickly which led to severe clang in many taking Eurozone stock exchanges e.g. France and Germany.
[ Indexs for stock market exchanges in Germany and France ]
A terrible liquidness crunch slowed down the growing of the full Eurozone. All possible options for pulling investors had failed.
Impact on World
Bing the currency of some of the strongest economic systems in the universe, depreciation on the value of Euro caused heavy losingss to countries/institutions that held high militias of Euro. Suppose India held a‚¬1 billion of foreign militias and Euro depreciates by 5 % , so India loses $ 50 millions11.
Europeans constitute a major ball among all tourers in the universe. Because of this crisis, Europe was severely affected and therefore touristry industry suffered immense losingss across the universe.
Many Bankss and fiscal establishments borrow money from London Interbank Market at LIBOR11 ( London Interbank offer Rate ) . Due to riskiness of the market and liquidness crunch in Eurozone, drifting LIBOR was increasing. This made foreign adoption less moneymaking and investing chances reduced in other economic systems as good.
Similar to the Eurozone scenario, investors became risk-averse and started selling off investings in stock markets all over the universe. This made the stock markets dip and investors incurred immense losingss.
[ Nikkie 225 and Dow Jones Stock Indices, Source: Yokel Finance ]
By October, 2009 when George Papandreou became the Prime Minister of Greece it was rather clear that the Greece Economy was on the brink of prostration and needed pressing restructuring. Pandereos ‘ Government unveiled a series of financial consolidation steps to cut down authorities outgo but the decrease in the Greece economic end product and the big debts already owed by Greece made the restructuring procedure ineffective. To add to that the outputs on Grecian bonds started increasing and it became progressively hard for Greece to sell new bonds to pay back the debt which was maturating. By March 29, 2010 Financial markets looses religion in Greece ‘s ability to serve its debt and it becomes progressively clear that Greece will either hold to reconstitute its debt or other EU states will hold to bail it out. Let us analyze the two options which were available to Greece and the effects of those options
Debt Restructuring was the initial option which was considered by Greece as a manner to come out of the debt trap. But it was fraught with many hazards. Once bond holders feel that autonomous debt issued by little euro zone states with high shortages is non unafraid there may be a tally on other states like Ireland, Portugal etc, taking to their prostration and a fiscal contagious disease and perchance the prostration of the Euro individual currency. Besides most of the bonds issued by Greece are held by European and American Bankss. Banks whose balance sheets are already weak due to the mortgage crisis and the recession that followed might travel belly-up if they are asked to reconstitute their Grecian debt.
Bailout by Other EU states and IMF
There was initial resistance to the thought of bailout both in the states which will be bearing the cost of the bailout and in Greece itself. The stronger states like Germany and France who would hold to pick the major portion of the fingerstall felt that they had no duty to clean up the muss that Greece had created. There was besides unfavorable judgment that Greece had falsified its histories to fall in the Euro Zone and had really high authorities outgo. Citizens in Greece felt that they were giving up their fiscal sovereignty by holding to the rigorous footings of the bailout. But April 2010 both sides agree to a bailout as a restructuring of the debt will do a world-wide fiscal contagious disease and on April 23, 2010 a bailout bundle of 110 Billion Euros is announced12.
The bailout bundle devised by the EU and IMF had really rigorous conditions which Greece had to follow, the chief among them being a decrease in authorities shortage.
The Greece Government Unveiled a series of steps to convey down the Government Deficit from an estimated 13.6 % of GDP in 2009 to below 3 % by 201213. Some of these steps were
10 % decrease in the wage of the Prime Minister, Ministers and Secretary Generals of Ministries
Hiring Freeze in2010
Wage freezing and 12 % decrease in civil retainer ‘s pay allowances coupled with the decrease of Christmas, Easter and holiday fillips by 30 % ( the so called 13th and 14th wage
Abolition of executive fillips in the populace sector
Freeze of all public sector pensions
The Grecian authorities besides started a gross mobilisation thrust to increase it income. This thrust was of import as the gross aggregation of Greece authorities was peculiarly low chiefly because of big scale revenue enhancement equivocation and the black economic system. The step announced by the authorities were
Addition of VAT rates from 4,5 % , 9 % and 19 % to 5 % , 10 % and 21 % respectively14
Addition of excise revenue enhancement on luxury goods ( expensive autos, yachts etc )
One-off revenue enhancement of 1 % on personal incomes above 100,000 Euros
Introduction of an excise revenue enhancement for electricity
Addition of excise responsibilities on baccy, intoxicant and fuel
Addition of revenue enhancements on heritages and legacies
Possible effects of recovery schemes
Most Economists expect the combined execution of financial asceticism and gross mobilisation strategies to cut down the authorities shortages to manageable degrees. Particularly the addition VAT rates and increase in exercise responsibilities on intoxicant and baccy are expected to be non-evadable and therefore lead to increased gross coevals.
But many economic experts besides fear that Greece might travel into a 2nd recession because of the disbursement cuts. They site three grounds for this
Incidence of revenue enhancement equivocation is already really high in Greece. Increase in revenue enhancement rates will do even more equivocation.
Expansionary pecuniary policy to counterbalance for the decrease in financial disbursement is non possible as the pecuniary policy is set by the European Central Bank.
40 % of the Grecian economic system is based on authorities outgo. A Crisp decrease in authorities disbursement may direct Greece into a terrible recession.
Their frights can be summarized by the authoritative debt spiral theory. Harmonizing to this authorities imposes high revenue enhancements and drastic cuts in outgo in order to cut down its debt. But this leads to a decrease in the incomes of the people taking to a decrease in disbursement. This in bend leads to a decrease in the GDP of the state and hence an Addition in the Debt to GDP ratio15.
[ Debt Spiral ]
The PIIGS consists of Portugal Ireland Italy Greece and Spain. Together they make up 34 % of the Euro Zone economic system and all have issues with high Government debt16. All these economic systems suffer from Greece manner economic jobs but each is alone to some extent.
Ireland had a bubble economic system due to high private investing which was supported by really low revenue enhancements. There was besides a debt fueled building roar which went to break after the Lehman prostration. The attendant consequence on its Bankss required the authorities to bail them out seting terrible strains on it fundss
Italy was characterized by high rewards and an uncompetitive fabrication sector. The close prostration of Alitalia and its bailout besides added to the authorities debt.
Spain was characterized by a immense lodging bubble which rivaled that of the United States. It besides ran immense shortages with inexpensive imports doing its fabrication sector to contract.
Portugal had really high rewards doing it uncompetitive in fabrication. This resulted in a deficiency of private investing and hence a decelerating economic system.
The really possibility of Greece defaulting on its debt lead to an addition in the bond outputs of these states. This has been more so in recent yearss when Ireland besides had to be bailed out with a 90 Billion Euro bundle as shown by the undermentioned graphs.
[ Portugal 10 twelvemonth Government Bond outputs ]
[ Spain 10 twelvemonth Government Bond outputs ]
The addition in the bond outputs of these states makes it hard for them to borrow in the unfastened market and besides increases the sum of money they have to payout as involvement this automatically makes their fundss strained and therefore doing the investors ask for higher outputs. This barbarous circle may do the other states in the PIIGS grouping to default or seek a bailout. And unlike Greece which a comparatively little economic system and signifiers merely 2 % of the Euro Zone economic system the other states of PIIGS when set together organize 34 % of the economic end product of the Euro Zone. Hence bailing them will necessitate important sums of money, which the other EU provinces may happen difficult to raise.
Survival of Euro
Greece Debt crisis has raised inquiries sing the feasibleness of the European Monetary Union. Euro sceptics have pointed out that the pecuniary brotherhood is non backed by a larger political brotherhood doing each state to put its ain Fiscal policy. There is besides unfavorable judgment that one of the chief standards for a pecuniary brotherhood to work i.e. high mobility of Labour is non satisfied in the Euro Zone. But others feel that the crisis negotiations of a demand to hold better integrating between the member states and a stricter enforcing of the Stability and Growth Pact. Some even advocate the execution of a Euro broad Fiscal policy in order to forestall a Grecian manner crisis in the future17.
The Greece crisis besides brought to the forepart he imbalances between the northern economic systems like Germany who have led an export led growing theoretical account and high financial prudence which resulted in high economy and that of states like Greece who led an debt financed ingestion led economic system. It is expected that traveling in front states like Germany will spur its domestic ingestion and peripheral states like Greece will do their economic systems more competitory and spur the development of export industries.